Top OEMs for Dry Pit Pumps in Water & Wastewater Applications

Introduction

In the landscape of municipal and industrial water and wastewater treatment, the dry pit pump configuration remains a cornerstone of reliability, maintainability, and hydraulic versatility. Unlike submersible installations where the pump and motor are submerged in the process fluid, dry pit installations separate the fluid handling equipment from the wet well. The pump is installed in a dry, accessible vault, connected to the wet well via suction piping. This configuration offers distinct advantages regarding operator safety, ease of maintenance, and the longevity of electromechanical components.

Dry pit pumps—often referred to as conventional non-clog pumps, split-case pumps, or frame-mounted centrifugal pumps—serve critical roles in raw sewage lift stations, return activated sludge (RAS) recirculation, effluent pumping, and high-pressure water distribution. Because these pumps often operate continuously or in critical duty/standby cycles, the selection of the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) is a strategic decision that impacts the facility’s Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) for decades.

Read more4D-Printed Smart Materials For Water Treatment

The engineering challenge lies not merely in selecting a pump that meets a duty point (flow and head) but in specifying a machine capable of withstanding the rigors of the application. Issues such as solids handling, cavitation margin (NPSH), vibration resonance, and seal reliability are magnified in dry pit applications where pumps are often larger and operating pressures are higher. Furthermore, the shift toward non-clog hydraulic designs to combat modern waste streams (such as non-dispersible wipes) has forced OEMs to innovate rapidly.

This article provides a comprehensive engineering analysis of the top OEMs in the dry pit and conventional pump category. We evaluate manufacturers based on hydraulic coverage, mechanical robustness, serviceability, and application fit, specifically for consulting engineers and plant operations leadership.

How to Select This Pump Type

Read moreA Comparison Between Aerobic And Anaerobic Wastewater Treatment Technology

Selecting a dry pit pump requires a multi-dimensional analysis that moves beyond the basic pump curve. Engineers must evaluate the intersection of hydraulic performance, mechanical integrity, and operational reality. The following criteria are essential for a robust specification.

1. Hydraulic Performance and BEP Proximity

The life expectancy of a dry pit pump is directly correlated to where it operates on its performance curve relative to the Best Efficiency Point (BEP).

• Preferred Operating Region (POR): Ideally, the pump should operate between 70% and 120% of BEP. Operating outside this range increases radial loads on the shaft and bearings, leading to premature seal failure and vibration.
• Suction Conditions (NPSH): In dry pit applications, Net Positive Suction Head Available (NPSHa) is often a limiting factor, particularly if the station design involves significant suction lift or long suction piping with friction losses. The Net Positive Suction Head Required (NPSHr) by the OEM must be significantly lower than the NPSHa to prevent cavitation, which causes pitting on the impeller and destructive vibration.
• System Curves: Engineers must superimpose system curves (static head + friction losses) over the pump curve to ensure the pump operates effectively at both minimum and maximum static head conditions.

2. Solids Handling and Impeller Geometry

For wastewater applications, the ability to pass solids without clogging is paramount.

• Sphere Passing Capability: A standard specification for raw sewage is the ability to pass a 3-inch (76mm) spherical solid.
• Impeller Types:
  • Enclosed Non-Clog: High efficiency but tighter clearances; prone to ragging if wear rings degrade.
  • Semi-Open: capable of handling stringy materials; allows for clearance adjustment to restore efficiency.
  • Vortex/Recessed: Ideal for grit and sludge; the impeller creates a vacuum, and solids rarely touch the vanes, reducing wear, but at the cost of lower hydraulic efficiency.
  • Screw/Chopper: Specialized designs for heavy ragging environments.

3. Materials of Construction

Material selection dictates the pump’s resistance to corrosion and abrasion.

• Volute/Casing: Typically Class 30 Cast Iron. For higher pressures, Ductile Iron is preferred due to its tensile strength.
• Impeller: While Cast Iron is standard, High-Chrome Iron or Duplex Stainless Steel (CD4MCu) is recommended for abrasive grit or corrosive industrial effluents to prevent rapid erosion.
• Shafting: Carbon steel shafts should be sleeved with stainless steel in the seal area, or constructed entirely of stainless steel to prevent corrosion-induced seal failure.

4. Bearing Life and Shaft Deflection

Mechanical reliability is defined by the shaft and bearing system.

• L10 Bearing Life: Specifications should mandate a minimum L10 bearing life of 50,000 to 100,000 hours at the worst-case operating point. This statistical measure ensures that 90% of bearings will survive this duration.
• Stiffness Ratio: The shaft design (specifically the ratio of the shaft overhang to the shaft diameter) determines deflection. Excessive deflection (L3/D4 ratio) at the seal face allows process fluid to leak, destroying bearings. A stiff shaft design is non-negotiable for dry pit pumps.

5. Maintenance and Serviceability

The primary advantage of a dry pit pump is accessibility.

• Back Pull-Out Design: This feature allows the rotating assembly (impeller, shaft, bearing frame) to be removed from the volute without disturbing the suction or discharge piping. This drastically reduces maintenance downtime.
• Seal Cartridges: Split mechanical seals or cartridge seals simplify replacement, eliminating the need for complex measurements and setting of seal spring compression.
• Cleanouts: Hand-hole cleanouts on the volute and suction elbow enable operators to remove blockages without disassembling the pump.

6. Mechanical Seals and Flush Plans

The mechanical seal is the most common point of failure.

• Single vs. Double Seals: Single seals are common for clean water. Double mechanical seals are standard for sewage to provide a barrier fluid.
• API Flush Plans: The specification must define the flush plan. Plan 53 (pressurized barrier fluid) or Plan 54 (external flush) are common. Water-flushed seals require a reliable source of clean water, whereas oil-lubricated seals are self-contained but run hotter.

Comparison Table: Top OEMs for Dry Pit Pumps

The following table analyzes the specified OEMs based on their conventional, dry-pit pump portfolios. Note that “Best-Fit” implies the application where the manufacturer historically excels, though all listed OEMs have broad capabilities.

Top OEM Manufacturers: Detailed Analysis

The following section provides a detailed engineering review of the specific OEMs permitted for the “Dry Pit / Conventional” category. This analysis focuses on their manufacturing philosophy, technical merits, and positioning within the water infrastructure market.

Goulds Pumps (Xylem)

Overview: As a brand under the Xylem umbrella, Goulds Pumps represents one of the oldest and most respected names in the fluid handling industry. While Xylem’s Flygt brand dominates the submersible market, Goulds serves as the heavyweight for conventional dry pit applications, particularly where American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standards or heavy industrial robustness is required.

Technical Focus: Goulds is renowned for the 3196 series (ANSI standard), which, while industrial, finds use in chemical dosing and sludge processing. However, for bulk water transfer, their double-suction split-case pumps (3400 series) and vertical non-clog lines are industry standards. Their designs emphasize heavy shafting and oversized bearings, often exceeding the minimum L10 life requirements specified by municipal codes.

Engineer’s Perspective: Specifying Goulds often provides a “safe” choice due to the ubiquity of service centers. Their i-ALERT condition monitoring technology is also increasingly integrated into their frames, allowing for vibration and temperature monitoring out of the box.

KSB

Overview: KSB is a German manufacturer that has deeply penetrated the global municipal market. In the realm of dry pit pumps, KSB is distinguished by its hydraulic sophistication. The Sewatec and KWP lines are dedicated dry-installed volute casing pumps designed specifically for wastewater.

Technical Focus: KSB’s primary differentiator is the research invested in impeller geometry to combat modern solids. Their free-flow and multi-channel impellers are optimized to maintain high hydraulic efficiency without sacrificing solids-passing capability. KSB also utilizes proprietary wear-resistant materials (like Norihard) for their wetted parts, making them a top choice for grit chambers or stations with high sand content.

Engineer’s Perspective: Engineers select KSB when efficiency is a primary driver (e.g., green building initiatives or high-energy cost regions). Their pumps typically offer steep performance curves, allowing for stable control across a range of flows.

Flowserve

Overview: Flowserve is the result of the consolidation of several legendary pump brands, including Worthington, Ingersoll-Dresser (IDP), and Byron Jackson. Consequently, their dry pit offering is vast and leans heavily toward large-scale infrastructure. They are less common in small lift stations but dominant in major metropolitan treatment plants.

Technical Focus: Flowserve excels in custom-engineered solutions. Their concrete volute pumps and large vertical non-clog pumps are found in some of the world’s largest flood control and sewage transfer stations. They offer robust split-case pumps (LR series) that are renowned for ease of maintenance. The mechanical integrity of a Flowserve pump is generally designed for “severe duty,” utilizing heavy-duty bearing frames and stiff shaft designs to minimize deflection.

Engineer’s Perspective: Flowserve is the “heavy artillery.” If the application involves high pressures, extreme flows, or water hammer risks, Flowserve’s engineered heritage provides the necessary safety factors.

Sulzer

Overview: Sulzer, a Swiss industrial engineering and manufacturing firm, has a strong heritage in the wastewater sector, particularly following their acquisition of ABS. For dry pit applications, Sulzer focuses intensely on the “wastewater challenge”—specifically, the management of fibrous materials.

Technical Focus: The Contrablock impeller system is Sulzer’s defining feature in this category. It allows for the passage of large solids and rags by incorporating a cutting/tearing action at the impeller inlet, without being a full “grinder” pump that sacrifices flow. Their dry-installed pumps often feature clever hand-hole designs for quick blockage removal. Furthermore, Sulzer has pushed the envelope on Premium Efficiency motors (IE3/IE4) coupled with their hydraulics.

Engineer’s Perspective: Sulzer is often specified in “trouble spots”—stations that have a history of ragging or clogging. Their focus on reliability in difficult fluids makes them a favorite for screening channels and influent pumping.

Grundfos

Overview: Historically known for vertical multistage clean water pumps, Grundfos expanded aggressively into the wastewater and heavy municipal sector through the acquisition of US legacy brands like Yeomans, Chicago Pump, and Morris. This gives them a legitimate portfolio of heavy-duty dry pit non-clog pumps.

Technical Focus: The S-Tube impeller is a significant innovation from Grundfos, offering a tube-shaped impeller that provides the free passage of a vortex impeller with the efficiency of a channel impeller. In dry pit configurations, Grundfos pumps are often sold as complete packages, including the dedicated Grundfos controls (CUE drives) which optimize the specific pump curve.

Engineer’s Perspective: Grundfos is an excellent choice for municipalities looking for integration. The synergy between their pumps, motors, and controls simplifies SCADA integration. The legacy Yeomans line is still supported and respected for heavy sewage duty.

Aurora Pump (Pentair)

Overview: A brand under Pentair, Aurora Pump is a staple in the North American market, particularly for clean water, HVAC, and commercial plumbing. However, their 600 Series Spher-Flo non-clog pumps are widely used in municipal lift stations.

Technical Focus: Aurora pumps are designed for standardization and ease of maintenance. Their horizontal and vertical split-case pumps (410 series) are industry workhorses for potable water distribution. While they may not offer the exotic metallurgies of KSB or the massive scale of Flowserve, they offer solid, reliable cast iron and bronze construction that meets AWWA and Hydraulic Institute standards.

Engineer’s Perspective: Aurora is often the “value engineering” champion. They provide reliable performance at a competitive price point. For standard municipal water booster stations or low-grit wastewater applications, Aurora provides excellent ROI.

Peerless Pump

Overview: Peerless Pump is synonymous with the vertical turbine pump, but their horizontal split-case and dry pit capabilities are equally formidable. Peerless has a reputation for extremely long lifecycles—it is not uncommon to find Peerless pumps operating for 40+ years in municipal water plants.

Technical Focus: The AE Series (horizontal split case) is their flagship for water transmission. These pumps feature double-suction impellers that hydraulically balance axial loads, extending bearing life significantly. For wastewater, they offer vertical non-clog configurations that leverage their deep expertise in vertical shafting and column assemblies.

Engineer’s Perspective: Peerless is the go-to for clean water applications (potable distribution, high service pumps). While capable in wastewater, their brand strength is strongest in clean water handling where hydraulic balance and smooth operation are critical.

Application Fit Guidance

Not all pumps are created equal, even within this elite list of OEMs. Based on field performance and design philosophy, here is a guide on where to apply each manufacturer.

1. Raw Sewage & Headworks (High Solids)

Primary Recommendations: KSB, Sulzer, Goulds.
This application demands superior solids handling. KSB’s free-flow hydraulics and Sulzer’s Contrablock technology are superior at preventing ragging, which is the number one operational headache in headworks. Goulds’ non-clog designs are also a robust standard.

2. Potable Water Distribution & High Service

Primary Recommendations: Peerless, Flowserve, Aurora, Goulds.
Here, efficiency and smooth hydraulic operation (low vibration) are key. Peerless and Flowserve excel in split-case designs that handle massive flows with minimal energy consumption. Aurora is excellent for mid-sized booster stations.

3. Return Activated Sludge (RAS)

Primary Recommendations: KSB, Goulds, Grundfos.
RAS pumps require gentle handling of biological floc to prevent shearing. KSB and Grundfos offer impellers designed for low-shear operation while maintaining the ability to pass occasional debris.

4. Large Scale / Flood Control

Primary Recommendations: Flowserve, Peerless.
When the flow rates exceed 20,000 GPM or heads are extreme, the custom engineering capabilities of Flowserve and Peerless are required. Their ability to fabricate large-scale casings and conduct full-scale testing is unmatched.

Engineer & Operator Considerations

Beyond the nameplate, the success of a dry pit pump installation depends on the ecosystem surrounding the equipment.

Maintenance Access and Safety

Dry pit pumps are preferred because they are accessible, but poor station design can negate this.

• Spacing: Engineers must provide at least 3 feet of clearance on all sides of the pump.
• Lifting Gear: A permanent monorail or bridge crane must be installed directly over the pump centerline. The weight of the motor and volute for dry pit pumps often exceeds the capacity of portable hoists.
• Heat Dissipation: Unlike submersibles cooled by the fluid, dry pit motors are air-cooled. The pump room must have adequate HVAC to remove the heat rejected by large motors (often 100HP+).

Spare Parts and Obsolescence

The “Standardization” argument is valid. If a municipality already has 50 Goulds pumps, adding a single KSB pump increases warehouse complexity.

• Stocking Strategy: For dry pit pumps, stocking a complete rotating assembly (shaft, impeller, bearings, seals pre-assembled) is the gold standard for critical redundancy. This allows a quick swap-out while the damaged assembly is rebuilt in the shop.
• OEM Support: Verify the local representative’s service capabilities. Do they have a local repair shop? Can they machine a shaft locally, or must it come from the factory?

Common Failure Modes to Mitigate

• Seal Failure via Dry Running: Even dry pit pumps can run dry if the suction valve is closed or the wet well level drops too low. Specifying seal protection relays and proper level controls is mandatory.
• Vibration: Dry pit pumps are rigidly coupled. Any misalignment during installation will destroy bearings. Laser alignment at startup is not optional—it is a requirement. Furthermore, piping strain (forcing piping to meet the flange) causes casing distortion and must be prohibited in the installation specs.

Conclusion

The dry pit pump remains the preferred choice for major municipal infrastructure where reliability and accessibility override the initial cost savings of submersible systems. While the fundamental technology of centrifugal pumping has not changed, the nuances of hydraulic design, material science, and efficiency have evolved.

For heavy sewage and high-ragging environments, OEMs like KSB and Sulzer offer hydraulic geometries that solve operational headaches at the source. For clean water and massive transmission mains, Peerless, Flowserve, and Aurora offer the stability and efficiency required for continuous duty. Goulds and Grundfos bridge the gap, offering versatile portfolios that can be adapted to almost any station requirement.

Engineers should approach the selection process by defining the fluid characteristics first, then the duty point, and finally the maintenance philosophy of the end-user. The “best” OEM is not the one with the highest efficiency on paper, but the one that offers the best intersection of hydraulic fit, local support, and mechanical robustness for the specific reality of the plant.