Top OEMs for Dewatering Pumps in Water & Wastewater Applications

1. Introduction

In the hierarchy of fluid handling equipment within municipal and industrial sectors, dewatering pumps occupy a unique and critical position. Unlike permanently installed process pumps designed for steady-state operations within a treatment plant, dewatering pumps are often tasked with transient, emergency, or variable-duty cycles in uncontrolled environments. For the consulting engineer and plant operator, these pumps represent the first line of defense against flooding, the primary mechanism for sewer bypass during infrastructure rehabilitation, and the essential utility for excavating and construction dewatering.

Dewatering applications in water and wastewater (W&WW) contexts are characterized by their severity. These pumps must handle fluids with high solids concentrations, varying viscosities, and unpredictable debris loads, often while operating under significant suction lift conditions. Furthermore, they frequently operate in “snore” conditions—where air and water are ingested simultaneously—which can induce cavitation and mechanical stress that would destroy standard process pumps. Whether deployed in a planned sewer bypass for a relining project or utilized for emergency stormwater removal during a hurricane, the reliability of the dewatering equipment is paramount. Failure can result in environmental non-compliance, regulatory fines, and catastrophic infrastructure damage.

The selection of an Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) for dewatering pumps requires a distinct set of evaluation criteria compared to stationary pumps. The focus shifts heavily toward portability, priming speed, run-dry capability, and field serviceability. This article provides an in-depth, technical analysis of the leading OEMs in the dewatering sector: Godwin (Xylem), Tsurumi, Gorman-Rupp, Thompson Pump, and Cornell Pump. It aims to guide engineers and decision-makers through the specification process, ensuring that the selected equipment aligns with the hydraulic realities and operational demands of modern water infrastructure.

2. How to Select Dewatering Pumps

Specifying a dewatering pump involves balancing hydraulic requirements with the physical constraints of the deployment site. Unlike a pump sitting on a baseplate in a climate-controlled dry pit, a dewatering pump is often subjected to the elements, dragged across rough terrain, and expected to perform immediately upon startup. The following criteria are essential for technical specification.

Hydraulic Performance and Suction Lift

The defining characteristic of a surface-mounted dewatering pump is its ability to lift water. Engineers must carefully calculate the Net Positive Suction Head Available (NPSHa). In dewatering scenarios, the static suction lift often approaches the theoretical limits of physics (approximately 28 feet at sea level, though practical limits are lower). Selection must prioritize pumps with high NPSH margins.

• Priming Systems: For non-submersible units, the method of priming is the most critical mechanical differentiator. Options include Venturi-based systems (using compressed air), diaphragm vacuum pumps, and oil-lubricated vacuum compressors. The speed of priming and the ability to re-prime automatically during surging flows are vital for unmanned operations.
• Snore Capability: As water levels drop, the pump will ingest air. The pump must be capable of running in this “snore” state without overheating the seal faces or losing prime capability for the next surge.

Solids Handling and Impeller Geometry

Dewatering influent is rarely clean water. It often contains rags, grit, stones, and suspended sludge.

• Free Passage: Specifications should mandate a minimum spherical solids handling capability, typically ranging from 3 inches (75mm) for general sewage bypass to smaller diameters for high-head clean water applications.
• Impeller Type:
  • Open/Semi-Open: Preferred for trash handling; allows for wear plate adjustment to maintain efficiency.
  
  Read more4D-Printed Smart Materials For Water Treatment
  • Enclosed: Higher efficiency but higher risk of clogging; generally less desirable for raw sewage dewatering unless protected by a cutter or screen.
  • Vortex/Recessed: Ideal for abrasive slurries or delicate solids, but usually sacrifices hydraulic efficiency.

Materials of Construction

Lifecycle cost is driven by wear resistance.

• Volute and Impeller: Standard specification is often Ductile Iron (ASTM A536). However, for abrasive environments (grit chambers, sand-heavy excavation), High-Chrome Iron or CD4MCu Duplex Stainless Steel provides superior hardness and corrosion resistance.
• Wear Plates: Adjustable wear plates are mandatory for open impellers. Hardened materials (e.g., Brinell 500+) extend the service intervals between adjustments.
• Mechanical Seals: Silicon Carbide vs. Silicon Carbide (SiC/SiC) is the industry standard for the primary seal due to its hardness and heat dissipation properties. Tungsten Carbide is an alternative for extreme shock loading.

Drive Systems and Environmental Compliance

Most dewatering pumps are autonomous units driven by diesel engines or electric motors.

• Diesel (Tier 4 Final): For portable, off-grid applications. Engineers must consider the maintenance implications of Tier 4 Final engines, including Diesel Exhaust Fluid (DEF) management and regeneration cycles. Extended run-time fuel tanks (24+ hours) are a critical specification for storm response.
• Electric Drive: Preferred for urban environments or long-term bypass where power is available. Electric units eliminate fueling logistics and reduce noise but require Soft Start or VFD panels to manage inrush current.

Reliability and Run-Dry Protection

Dewatering pumps frequently run dry when the sump is emptied. The mechanical seal system must be designed to survive this. Oil-bath mechanical seals, which lubricate the faces even in the absence of pumped fluid, are a critical design feature. Some OEMs utilize backup seal cooling systems that circulate glycol or oil to prevent thermal cracking of seal faces during dry operation.

3. Comparison Table: Dewatering OEM Analysis

Read moreA Comparison Between Aerobic And Anaerobic Wastewater Treatment Technology

The following table provides a technical comparison of the locked list of OEMs. This analysis focuses on their primary market positioning and technical attributes relevant to consulting engineers and plant operations.

4. Top OEM Manufacturers

The following section details the engineering philosophy and technical portfolio of the specific OEMs identified for the dewatering category. These manufacturers have been selected based on their prevalence in the North American municipal and industrial markets.

Godwin (Xylem)

Overview: Under the Xylem umbrella, Godwin is arguably the most recognizable name in portable dewatering, particularly regarding the “Dri-Prime” series. Their market dominance is built on the CD (Contractor Dewatering) and NC (Non-Clog) series.

Technical Analysis: Godwin’s core differentiator is the Venturi air-ejector priming system. This utilizes compressed air blown through a nozzle to create a vacuum, allowing the pump to prime from dry conditions to 28 feet of static lift. Because the system does not rely on moving parts within the priming mechanism itself (unlike a diaphragm pump), it is highly resistant to wear. The NC series features Flygt N-Technology hydraulics (self-cleaning impellers) integrated into a surface-mounted diesel package, providing excellent non-clogging performance for fibrous municipal sewage. Engineers often specify Godwin for critical path projects where failure is not an option and where remote monitoring (via Xylem’s FieldSmart) is required to track fuel levels and pump health.

Tsurumi

Overview: Tsurumi approaches dewatering primarily from a submersible standpoint. While they offer engine-driven pumps, their reputation among engineers and operators is cemented by their electric submersible lines (LB, NK, KTZ series).

Technical Analysis: Tsurumi’s engineering philosophy centers on durability and waterproofing. A critical specification point is their proprietary “Anti-Wicking Block” at the cable entry. In many submersibles, if the cable jacket is cut, water travels down the copper strands into the motor housing via capillary action. Tsurumi’s design seals the conductors, preventing this common failure mode. Additionally, many Tsurumi models feature high-chrome iron impellers and agitators as standard, making them exceptionally resilient in abrasive, sandy water found in construction and stormwater applications. Their design allows for “top discharge,” which cools the motor via the pumped fluid, allowing for extended operation at low water levels.

Gorman-Rupp

Overview: Gorman-Rupp is a titan in the self-priming centrifugal market. While famous for their permanent lift station pumps (Super T Series), their portable dewatering line (Prime Aire and PA Series) is a staple in municipal fleets.

Technical Analysis: The Gorman-Rupp PA Series utilizes a pump-end that mimics their standard self-priming architecture but adds a diaphragm-operated priming assist to handle air-entrained fluids and rapid re-priming. A key feature for maintenance supervisors is the external shimless wear plate adjustment. As the impeller and wear plate degrade, clearance opens up, and efficiency drops. Gorman-Rupp allows operators to close this tolerance externally with hand tools, restoring hydraulic efficiency without disassembling the volute. Their “ReliaPrime” system provides a venturi-based alternative for specific applications. The robust nature of their casting and bearing frames makes them a preferred choice for long-term bypass operations where equipment abuse is expected.

Thompson Pump

Overview: Thompson Pump is highly regarded for its engineering innovation in the priming system, specifically addressing environmental concerns associated with traditional priming methods.

Technical Analysis: Thompson’s “Enviroprime” system is a compressor-assisted priming mechanism. In older or less sophisticated priming systems, as the priming chamber fills with water, there is a risk of the fluid (sewage) being ejected out of the priming exhaust onto the ground (blow-by). The Enviroprime system uses an oil-less compressor and a secondary air/water separation chamber to ensure that only air is expelled, keeping the sewage contained within the system. This is a critical specification requirement for projects in environmentally sensitive areas or urban centers. Thompson pumps also feature heavy-duty ductile iron constructions and are frequently utilized in wellpoint dewatering, where handling large volumes of air continuously is required.

Cornell Pump

Overview: Cornell is synonymous with high efficiency and robust hydraulic design. While they provide complete packages, their “pump ends” are often the heart of custom dewatering builds.

Technical Analysis: Cornell’s defining technology for dewatering is the “Cycloseal” system. This design incorporates deflector vanes in the seal chamber backplate that create a cyclonic action. This action spins solids and abrasive grit away from the mechanical seal faces, significantly extending seal life in dirty water applications. Combined with their “Redi-Prime” system (a vacuum-assisted priming add-on), Cornell pumps offer some of the highest efficiency points (BEP) in the industry. For engineers concerned with fuel consumption over long-duration projects (e.g., a 6-month mine dewatering effort), Cornell’s hydraulic efficiency often results in the lowest Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) due to diesel savings.

5. Application Fit Guidance

Matching the specific OEM strengths to the application is vital for successful project execution. The following guide delineates where each manufacturer typically excels.

Municipal Wastewater (Sewer Bypass)

Primary Choice: Godwin, Gorman-Rupp, Thompson Pump.

Rationale: These applications require rapid self-priming, high solids handling capabilities (rags, wipes), and strict environmental containment. Godwin’s NC series and Thompson’s Enviroprime are specifically engineered to prevent clogging and fluid discharge. Gorman-Rupp is favored by municipalities that already stock GR parts for their permanent stations.

Industrial Wastewater & Sludge

Primary Choice: Tsurumi, Godwin.

Rationale: For tank cleaning and sump evacuation where electric power is available, Tsurumi’s agitator pumps are excellent for suspending settled solids. Godwin’s HL (High Head) series is often used for pumping industrial slurry over long distances.

Stormwater and Flood Control

Primary Choice: Godwin, Thompson Pump.

Rationale: These scenarios require massive flow rates and portability. The focus here is on “trash handling” rather than fibrous solids. High-volume axial flow or mixed flow dewatering pumps from these manufacturers are standard. Reliability of the diesel engine in adverse weather is the deciding factor.

High-Head & Mine Dewatering

Primary Choice: Cornell Pump, Godwin.

Rationale: When water needs to be moved vertically out of a deep quarry or mine, or pumped miles away, hydraulic efficiency and pressure capability are key. Cornell’s high-head series is the industry benchmark here, offering heads exceeding 800 feet in single-stage or series configurations.

Construction & Excavation (General Purpose)

Primary Choice: Tsurumi, Generic Trash Pumps.

Rationale: For keeping a foundation dry, electric submersibles (Tsurumi) are preferred because they are quiet, emission-free (in the pit), and run autonomously. If power isn’t available, smaller diesel units from the other OEMs are utilized.

6. Engineer & Operator Considerations

Beyond the catalog data, practical considerations determine the long-term success of dewatering equipment. Engineers and operators should incorporate the following into their specifications and maintenance protocols.

Maintenance Access and Serviceability

Dewatering pumps are high-maintenance items by nature of their application.

• Access Ports: Look for pumps with large, easily accessible clean-out ports. If a pump clogs with a rag ball at 2:00 AM, the operator needs to clear it safely without disassembling the suction piping.
• Belt Tensioning: On diesel units, verify the method of belt tensioning. Automatic tensioners reduce maintenance, while manual systems require vigilance to prevent belt slippage and premature bearing wear.
• Seal Changes: Evaluate how difficult it is to change the mechanical seal. Cartridge seals are preferred for speed, though they are more expensive than component seals.

Spare Parts Availability

In emergency dewatering, lead time is the enemy.

• Regional Support: Engineers should favor OEMs with strong local distribution and rental depots. Godwin and Gorman-Rupp maintain massive rental fleets, which doubles as a supply chain for spare parts.
• Interchangeability: For fleets, standardization is key. Using one OEM allows for stocking a single type of filter, seal kit, and wear plate, reducing inventory costs.

Common Specification Mistakes

• Ignoring NPSHa: The most common failure is cavitation caused by placing the pump too high above the water source. Engineers must account for altitude, water temperature, and suction friction losses.
• Oversizing the Pump: Specifying a pump that is too large causes it to run on the far left of the curve, leading to recirculation cavitation, vibration, and shaft deflection.
• Neglecting Sound Attenuation: In urban bypass projects, noise complaints can shut down a job site. “Critically Silenced” or “Hospital Grade” enclosures (reducing noise to ~65-70 dBA at 30 feet) should be specified for residential areas.

7. Conclusion

The selection of dewatering pumps for water and wastewater applications is a critical engineering decision that impacts operational continuity and environmental compliance. While the fundamental physics of centrifugal pumping apply across all brands, the differentiation lies in the priming technologies, solids handling strategies, and packaging execution.

For large-scale, critical sewer bypass and flood control, Godwin and Thompson Pump offer sophisticated priming systems and environmental protections that mitigate risk. Gorman-Rupp provides a robust, operator-friendly solution ideal for municipalities prioritizing maintenance accessibility and longevity. Tsurumi dominates the electric submersible niche with unmatched durability in abrasive environments, while Cornell Pump stands out for high-efficiency, high-head applications where fuel economy and seal life are paramount.

Engineers and plant managers must look beyond initial purchase price and evaluate the Total Cost of Ownership, considering fuel consumption, seal replacement intervals, and the cost of potential downtime. By aligning the specific hydraulic and environmental constraints of the project with the unique engineering strengths of these top OEMs, utilities can ensure resilient and reliable fluid management operations.