Top OEMs for Horizontal End Suction Pumps in Water & Wastewater Applications

Introduction to Horizontal End Suction Pumps in Water & Wastewater

In the complex hydraulic landscape of municipal and industrial water treatment, the horizontal end suction pump remains the ubiquitous workhorse. While vertical turbine pumps may dominate deep well applications and submersible pumps handle the depths of wet wells, the horizontal end suction (HES) configuration is the standard specification for accessible, dry-pit applications where maintenance ease, hydraulic flexibility, and capital efficiency intersect.

A horizontal end suction pump is defined by its specific architectural configuration: a single impeller, a horizontal shaft, a volute casing with a suction connection on the end (axial), and a discharge connection on the top (radial). This design simplicity belies its critical role. From potable water booster stations and filtrate pumping to chemical dosing and sludge recirculation, HES pumps are integral to the process flow diagram of nearly every treatment facility.

Read more4D-Printed Smart Materials For Water Treatment

For consulting engineers and plant operators, the ubiquity of this pump type presents a paradox. Because they are common, they are often commoditized in specifications, treated as interchangeable “off-the-shelf” components. However, in the rigorous environment of Water and Wastewater (W/WW) treatment, slight nuances in Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) design—bearing frame stiffness, shaft deflection ratios, sealing chamber geometry, and impeller architecture—can dictate the difference between a 20-year lifecycle and a maintenance nightmare.

This article provides a rigorous technical analysis of the top OEMs producing horizontal end suction pumps specifically for the water and wastewater sectors. It moves beyond marketing literature to examine the engineering philosophies, hydraulic envelopes, and mechanical reliabilities of the leading manufacturers.

How to Select This Pump Type: Engineering Criteria

Read moreA Comparison Between Aerobic And Anaerobic Wastewater Treatment Technology

Selecting the correct horizontal end suction pump requires a multidimensional analysis that goes beyond the basic duty point (Flow and Head). Engineers must evaluate the unit against the specific constraints of the fluid being pumped and the operational philosophy of the facility.

1. Hydraulic Performance and System Curves

The intersection of the pump curve and the system curve is fundamental, but in HES selection, the position of the Best Efficiency Point (BEP) is critical. Consulting engineers should specify pumps where the operating point falls to the left of BEP, typically between 80% and 110% of BEP. Operating too far left leads to suction recirculation and thermal instability; operating too far right leads to cavitation and excessive vibration.

Furthermore, the shape of the curve matters. For variable speed applications (VFD driven), a steep curve is often preferred to allow for more precise control over pressure variations. In parallel pumping configurations, often found in booster stations, stable curves (where head continuously rises to shutoff) are mandatory to prevent hunting and surging between pumps.

2. Standards: ANSI B73.1 vs. ISO 2858 vs. General Service

Not all end suction pumps are built to the same code.

• ANSI B73.1 (Chemical Duty): Originally designed for the chemical industry, these pumps feature heavy-duty bearing frames, open impellers for solids handling, and standardized dimensions. They are robust and preferred for sludge, chemicals, and harsh wastewater applications.
• ISO 2858 / 5199: The metric equivalent to ANSI, common in facilities with European design influence. They offer similar robustness and dimensional interchangeability within the ISO framework.
• General Service / Water Norm: These pumps are often cast iron, close-coupled or frame-mounted units designed specifically for clean water. They are cost-effective but generally lack the shaft stiffness and corrosion resistance required for aggressive wastewater or chemical service.

3. Impeller Architecture and Solids Handling

In W/WW, the fluid often dictates the impeller.

• Enclosed Impellers: Offer the highest efficiency. Best for clean water, final effluent, or potable water boosting. They rely on tight wear ring clearances which will degrade rapidly if grit is present.
• Semi-Open Impellers: The standard for ANSI pumps. They can handle higher solids concentrations and stringy materials. Clearance is adjustable from the bearing housing (dialing in the impeller), allowing operators to restore efficiency as wear occurs without replacing parts.
• Vortex / Recessed Impellers: Used when passing large solids is paramount and efficiency is secondary. The impeller sits back in the volute, creating a fluid coupling. Ideal for grit pumping or raw sewage with high rag content.

4. Mechanical Seals and Flushing Plans

The mechanical seal is the most common point of failure in HES pumps.

• Component vs. Cartridge: Cartridge seals are preferred for ease of installation, eliminating setting errors.
• Flush Plans: For clean water, a Plan 11 (discharge recirculation) is standard. For wastewater containing abrasives, a Plan 53 (barrier fluid) or Plan 54 (external source) may be necessary to protect the seal faces. Engineers must ensure the stuffing box design allows for adequate heat dissipation and solids evacuation.

5. Coupling Arrangements

• Close-Coupled: The pump impeller is mounted directly to the motor shaft. This eliminates alignment issues and reduces footprint. However, if the seal fails, fluid can spray into the motor bearings. It also makes seal changes difficult as the motor must be removed.
• Frame-Mounted (Flexible Coupled): The pump has its own bearing housing and shaft, connected to the motor via a coupling. This is the preferred specification for municipal/industrial applications. It isolates the motor from hydraulic loads and heat, allows for “Back Pull-Out” maintenance (removing the rotating assembly without disturbing piping or motor), and utilizes heavy-duty pump bearings (L10h > 50,000 hours).

Comparison Table: Horizontal End Suction OEMs

The following table analyzes the allowed OEMs based on their specific strengths within the horizontal end suction category for water and wastewater applications.

Top OEM Manufacturers: Detailed Analysis

The following analysis evaluates the designated manufacturers based strictly on their horizontal end suction portfolios. It avoids marketing language to focus on the engineering attributes that matter to specifiers and end-users.

Goulds Pumps (Xylem)

Engineering Heritage: Goulds Pumps is arguably the most recognizable name in the end suction market, primarily due to the Model 3196. This pump effectively established the ANSI B73.1 standard for dimension and performance. In the wastewater sector, Goulds is the go-to specification for process-critical applications where failure is not an option.

Technical Differentiators:

• Shaft Stiffness: The 3196 series is engineered with a shaft stiffness ratio (L³/D⁴) that minimizes deflection at the seal faces to less than 0.002 inches. This extends mechanical seal life significantly, which is the primary lifecycle cost driver.
• Impeller Options: Goulds offers a wide array of open and enclosed impellers, including the Xducer for specific duties. Their open impeller design allows for external clearance adjustment, crucial for maintaining efficiency in abrasive wastewater service without disassembling the pump.
• Material Science: Goulds has extensive foundry capabilities, offering higher alloys like CD4MCu (Duplex Stainless Steel) as standard upgrades over 316SS, providing superior resistance to the chlorides and H2S found in wastewater.

Best Fit: Chemical dosing (ferric chloride, alum), sludge transfer, and grit applications where robust ANSI construction is required.

Grundfos

Engineering Heritage: Grundfos approaches the end suction market with a philosophy deeply rooted in energy efficiency and electronic integration. While they produce robust mechanical iron, their differentiation lies in the “wire-to-water” efficiency.

Technical Differentiators:

• NB/NBG and NK/NKG Series: These are ISO 2858 compliant pumps. The “NK” indicates a long-coupled (frame-mounted) design, which is preferred for ease of maintenance.
• Electro-Coating: Grundfos applies a cationic electro-deposition coating (e-coat) to cast iron components, providing high corrosion resistance for general plant environments.
• Integrated Electronics: Grundfos excels in pairing pumps with their MGE motors (integrated VFDs). For variable demand applications, such as water booster stations, this single-source responsibility for the drive and the pump motor simplifies commissioning and compatibility issues.

Best Fit: Potable water distribution, plant water reuse systems, and clean water boosting where energy efficiency (wire-to-water) is the primary evaluation criteria.

KSB

Engineering Heritage: KSB is a German engineering giant with a massive global footprint. Their designs adhere strictly to ISO standards and are characterized by hydraulic precision. In the US market, they bridge the gap between municipal water transport and industrial process needs.

Technical Differentiators:

• MegaCPK: This is KSB’s flagship chemical/process pump. It is designed with hydraulic optimization that often yields lower Net Positive Suction Head required (NPSHr) values than competitors, making it a problem-solver for systems with poor suction conditions or high temperatures.
• Etanorm: The world’s best-selling standardized water pump. Its reliability stems from a stiff shaft design and confined casing gaskets that prevent blowouts under pressure surges.
• Advanced Hydraulics: KSB invests heavily in Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Their volute designs are optimized to reduce radial thrust across the operating range, not just at the Best Efficiency Point (BEP).

Best Fit: Raw water intake, large-scale cooling loops, and difficult suction lift applications where NPSH margin is tight.

Flowserve

Engineering Heritage: Flowserve’s portfolio includes the heritage of Durco and Worthington. The Durco Mark 3 is a legend in the chemical processing industry and has been adopted by the wastewater industry for the most aggressive applications.

Technical Differentiators:

• Reverse Vane Impeller: Unique to the Durco line, this impeller design puts the wear surface on the rear cover rather than the casing. This reduces seal chamber pressure and requires only one setting adjustment, simplifying maintenance.
• SealGard: The bearing isolator technology used by Flowserve is superior to standard lip seals, preventing the ingress of wash-down water and contaminants into the bearing housing.
• Heavy Duty Power Ends: The Mark 3 power end is designed for severe loads, utilizing a double-row angular contact outboard bearing that handles significant axial thrust.

Best Fit: Aggressive chemical feed (acids/caustics), polymer transfer, and industrial wastewater treatment where corrosion and abrasion are the main threats.

Aurora Pump (Pentair)

Engineering Heritage: Aurora has a century-long history in municipal water and fire protection. Their designs are conservative, heavy, and built for longevity in general service applications.

Technical Differentiators:

• 3800 Series: This is a split-coupled, inline end suction pump, but their standard frame-mounted end suction (340/360 series) is the staple. They utilize a vacuum casting process that results in smoother internal waterways and higher consistent efficiencies.
• Case Rings: Aurora typically designs with replaceable case wear rings even on smaller sizes, allowing for cost-effective refurbishment rather than volute replacement.
• Diverse Metallurgies: While standardizing on cast iron/bronze fitted, Aurora supports all-iron and stainless steel fitted construction for varying water qualities.

Best Fit: Municipal water booster stations, backwash pumps, and general utility service where a rugged, uncomplicated pump is required.

Peerless Pump

Engineering Heritage: Peerless is synonymous with reliability in the stationary fire pump market, but their AE series end suction pumps share that DNA of reliability. They focus on the process capability of the pump.

Technical Differentiators:

• AE Series: The Peerless AE pump is designed to be a “drop-in” replacement for many legacy ANSI installations but with specific tweaks for water service.
• Dynamic Design: Peerless offers centerline discharge on many models, which simplifies piping stress analysis and reduces the footprint compared to tangential discharge volutes.
• Grooved Shafts: Some configurations utilize a grooved shaft design at the locking mechanism to ensure positive drive without the stress risers associated with standard keyways in high-torque starts.

Best Fit: Retrofits in existing municipal plants, non-potable water systems, and general circulation.

Bell & Gossett (Xylem)

Engineering Heritage: While Bell & Gossett (B&G) dominates the commercial HVAC market, their Series 1510 and e-1510 pumps are heavily utilized in the “clean” side of wastewater plants. They are the reference standard for base-mounted end suction pumps.

Technical Differentiators:

• True Back Pull-Out: B&G perfected the spacer coupling design that allows the entire bearing assembly and impeller to be removed while the motor and volute remain bolted to the baseplate and piping. This is a massive labor saver.
• Alignment Ease: The baseplates used by B&G are open and heavily reinforced, reducing the likelihood of “soft foot” and making laser alignment straightforward.
• Comparison to ANSI: Unlike the Goulds 3196, the B&G e-1510 is not designed for slurry. It is a tight-tolerance, high-efficiency machine for water.

Best Fit: Hot water loops for anaerobic digester heating, mechanical seal flush water pressure boosting, and HVAC systems within plant buildings.

Application Fit Guidance

Matching the OEM to the application is vital for avoiding gold-plating (overspecifying) or under-designing the system.

Municipal Wastewater (Headworks & Treatment)

For chemical dosing (ferric, alum, methanol) and sludge recirculation, Goulds Pumps and Flowserve are the preferred choices. Their ANSI designs handle the corrosivity and the solids content effectively. For supernatant return or effluent water, Aurora and Peerless offer cost-effective, durable solutions.

Industrial Wastewater

Industrial applications often involve higher temperatures and aggressive pH levels. Flowserve (Durco) excels here due to their material science heritage. KSB is also a strong contender in this space, particularly for larger flow rates found in pulp and paper or petrochemical wastewater treatment.

Clean Water & Utility Service

For potable water boosting, seal water systems, and plant utility water, Grundfos and Bell & Gossett are the top contenders. Their focus on hydraulic efficiency and clean-water tolerances provides the lowest total cost of ownership (TCO) through energy savings.

Stormwater

While stormwater is often handled by vertical axial flow or submersible pumps, end suction pumps are used for dry-pit stormwater transfer in smaller stations. KSB and Aurora provide the necessary solids-passing capability in their larger frame-mounted units to handle the grit associated with stormwater.

Engineer & Operator Considerations

Beyond the nameplate, the long-term success of a horizontal end suction pump installation depends on operational factors that must be addressed during the design and commissioning phases.

1. Maintenance Access and Back Pull-Out

Operators frequently struggle with installations where piping obstructs the pump. Engineers must specify a “spacer coupling” for frame-mounted pumps. This allows the maintenance team to utilize the Back Pull-Out feature—removing the bearing unit and impeller without unbolting the motor or the casing. Without a spacer coupling, the motor must be moved to service the pump, necessitating a realignment every time the seal is changed.

2. Baseplate Stiffness and Grouting

A common failure mode in end suction pumps is vibration caused by a flexible baseplate. Stamped steel bases are insufficient for the torque and piping loads in W/WW plants. Engineers should specify cast iron or heavy-duty fabricated steel baseplates and require them to be fully grouted. This adds mass and damping to the system, significantly extending bearing life.

3. The L10h Bearing Life Trap

Standard commercial pumps often carry an L10h bearing life rating of 20,000 hours. In a 24/7 water plant, that is less than 2.5 years. For municipal applications, engineers should explicitly specify a minimum L10h bearing life of 50,000 to 100,000 hours at the Best Efficiency Point. OEMs like Goulds and KSB offer heavy-duty power ends specifically to meet these higher reliability targets.

4. Spare Parts Strategy

Goulds and Flowserve (ANSI types) offer high interchangeability. A plant can stock one size of power end (bearing frame) that fits 15 different liquid end (casing/impeller) sizes. This drastically reduces inventory costs. Grundfos and KSB may utilize proprietary components that are less interchangeable between sizes, requiring a more comprehensive spare parts audit.

5. Common Specification Mistakes

• Oversizing: Adding too much safety factor to the head calculation forces the pump to run to the left of BEP, increasing radial loads and causing shaft deflection.
• Ignoring NPSHa: Assuming sea-level atmospheric pressure in high-elevation plants or neglecting the vapor pressure of warm wastewater leads to chronic cavitation.
• Wrong Seal Plan: Specifying a Plan 11 (recirculation from discharge) on a pump handling grit will sandblast the seal faces. A Plan 53 or 54 should be used for dirty services.

Conclusion

The selection of a horizontal end suction pump manufacturer is not a choice between “good” and “bad,” but rather a pursuit of the optimal fit for the specific fluid and duty cycle.

For aggressive chemical metering and heavy sludge processing, the ANSI-heritage pumps from Goulds Pumps (Xylem) and Flowserve offer the robust mechanical design and material options required to survive. For clean water boosting and utility applications where efficiency is paramount, Grundfos and Bell & Gossett deliver superior energy performance and integrated controls. KSB, Aurora, and Peerless offer strong intermediate solutions, balancing robust hydraulics with broad application versatility across municipal infrastructure.

Engineers must move beyond verifying flow and head. By scrutinizing shaft stiffness, bearing life, seal environment capabilities, and maintenance accessibility, decision-makers can ensure that the ubiquitous end suction pump becomes a reliable asset rather than a recurring maintenance liability.